Pehpsi wrote:LOVE to get an 85 1.8. Not far away, any day now..
I looked back at my first ever band pics from the Hopetoun:
1600, 2.8, 1/100, 170mm, Auto WB, RAW, Centre Weight
I think I over-cooked them..?
Yep. Take 'em out of the oven a little earlier.
1/250 sounds about right, here, for this image.
The reds are difficult in the D70; it tends towards overcooking, which is exactly what you're seeing.
wb - incandescent and -2, but shoot raw.
Spot meter rather than cw, -1.7 EV comp as a starting point.
Chimp using the histogram - never, ever, rely on just the image playback display to establish exposure. Never. Expect the histogram to tend towards the left: you're shooting high contrast images with very dark backgrounds, so this is an expected outcome.
When you're happy with your exposure, note the settings, and then switch the camera to M; apply the noted settings.
Not for the Basement, but as a general guide, do not be afraid to use the built-in flash, or your SB-800, to provide an element of fill. Dial it back by at least 0.7, maybe even 1.7. It will help kill some of the red, and give you a better balanced image. And don't touch the wb.